Your Not A Real Brewer Unless You Gotta

[Yorkee]

Murray,

You mean that there have been others with the same opinion?

 

[Doc]

a hopback

Doc

 

[Batz]

Nice replies all,

But what is it that Pumpy and Batz refer to. Why do we need to go for the full mash!! When we can brew a very nice Coopers lager from a kit? Do some have more refined taste buds or what? Is it like doing the car - first you can change the oil and then with a bit of effort you can do the brakes and then, if you really try you can take the head off

HOW complicated can we make this process - or is that what we strive to do and understand.

Heavy stuff - as you like it

:huh: wtf? :huh:

 

[Pumpy]

Nice replies all,

But what is it that Pumpy and Batz refer to. Why do we need to go for the full mash!! When we can brew a very nice Coopers lager from a kit? Do some have more refined taste buds or what? Is it like doing the car - first you can change the oil and then with a bit of effort you can do the brakes and then, if you really try you can take the head off

HOW complicated can we make this process - or is that what we strive to do and understand.

Heavy stuff - as you like it

Yorkee .

You dont need to go too a full mash if you are happy with your Coopers Lager from a kit.

Life is all about choice. I suppose you only have choice if you have done both.!!

Otherwise you have no choice.

Pumpy

 

[Yorkee]

WTF?

The wrong thread? How is "you are not a real brewer unless you go all the way to a full mash" the wrong thread. Apologies, I am a new member and am just trying to contribute. WTF - WELCOME!!

 

[Mr Bond]

small Willy(Brewers droop) :lol: h34r:

or is it just ME?

@ 37 with 2 kids the" ol feller" has gone part time on an easing into retirement(50)plan any way.

beer is King(or should that be queen?)

 

[wee stu]

small Willy(Brewers droop) :

or is it just ME?

No, I have a fairly small willy too , but I have made good use of it

(I suspect I am going to regret this in the morning h34r: )

 

[Yorkee]

Ha Ha

 

[vlbaby]

small Willy(Brewers droop) :

or is it just ME?

No, I have a fairly small willy too , but I have made good use of it

(I suspect I am going to regret this in the morning h34r: )

they dont call you wee stu for nothin

 

[Batz]

WTF?

The wrong thread? How is "you are not a real brewer unless you go all the way to a full mash" the wrong thread. Apologies, I am a new member and am just trying to contribute. WTF - WELCOME!!

Sorry your correct not me

And your kits brews are great,better than I brew

Sorry again

Batz

 

[vlbaby]

Murray,

You mean that there have been others with the same opinion?

Yorkee,

62.4% of brewers here do a full mash. check out the 'all grain or extract thread'.



vl.

 

[Tony]

Yorkee......

you did start out with a fairly agressive stand.

QUOTE:

Why do we need to go for the full mash!! When we can brew a very nice Coopers lager from a kit?

To answer this question with a question...... how many AG lagers have you made.

to compare a coopers lager kit with an AG lager mashed with Pils malt and a bittered with fresh hops. I just did a post on grumpys explaning isohop eztract. ITs like comparing a fresh vanilla bean with a teaspoon of vanilla essence.

and some of us just like to make the effort to make something better than can be bought from the shops. all for 23c / schooner

everyone is welcome on here mate. It gets splashed around a bit that if your not an AG brewer you will get told to f*#k off on here but thats not the truth. we all start out as kit brewers. If AG brewing wasnt worth doing, do you think we would spend 6+ hrs in the shed/garage/kitchen/brewery slaving over hot liquid!!!

the toys we build to make the job a bit easier are just a bonus

chill and cheers dude.

and id rather a coopers lager over a VB any day

 

[Murray]

This may be the wrong thread, but I would say it is easier to make a good tasting lager AG than from a kit h34r:

 

[stephen]

Oh it is true as true as you are sitting on the pc THanks for the welcome, Promise I wont gate crash too much but posting for a stir serves tony right for leaving the site open :lol: Yes I am the boss

We knew it was you - the spelling improved...

 

[Yorkee]

Thanks Tony, Batz, Baby etc,

Wasn't meaning to be aggressive. I haven't had the pleasure of ever tasting a mash and it will probably be the way I go in the future. I suppose I was just asking if it is really worth all that extra time and effort - obviously it must be.

Batz - you flatter me mate, but I don't belive that my apprentice like efforts could get any where near your brews. Didn't mean to ruffle any feathers or wings

 

[bindi]

.....spend more time in the brewery than on the pc.....that's the problem

Batz
[/quote]


That has been the case for weeks now, I have to get 'a real job' and spend less time in the brewery, and less time on this site. .

 

[Weizguy]

Your not a brewer unless your wife can get on the pc and have a winge! Bloody starters keeping me up at night!
Tony's wife here

Tell me this is a very bad joke
please don't tell me this is true

Whats worse than your wife reading AHB posts over your shoulder?

Your wife posting when you are not around.

welcome MRS TONY, we know you are the boss anyway.

To further this "jungle of quotes", I have my own comment to make.

Having over a thousand posts now, and feeling superior after drinking out of my new Erdinger World Cup Weissbier glass, I feel the need to declare Tony guilty of a "beer crime"...that being the crime of remaining logged on to this site and allowing the security of his logon to be breached by the missus or SWMBO.

Tony must now scull 2 pints of his worst beer to atone for this beer crime. This may not be a problem if his worst beer is still a cracker.

Seth out

 

[Yorkee]

OK, Now I know that I may have had the wrong thread as I have just read the AG v Kit stuff threads.

I didn't realise the can of worms that I was opening when I asked the simple question as to if an AG was worth the trouble of the extra work and time when compared to a kit (Coopers Lager it was) Maybe it would be better if we had a separate forum for the AG and the rest and never the twain? My suggestion that brewing beer was like fixing the car wasn't a difficult analogy - or was it?

Maybe we kit men could pour sh*t on the brewers of ginger ale It looks to me that there are egos you can't jump over here.

Nice to see that some have the voice of reason and that in the end we are all drinking beer. My first post said that it was nice that the experts were willing to share their knowledge. Didn't know that we needed a referee.

 

[Murray]

The only people that have a problem are the people making the problem. This forum is a great resource for improving your techniques, whatever level you choose. Any 'battle' is purely in the mind of the guy trying to fight it.

 

[pint of lager]

Well said Murray.

Here endeth the battle.