Two more superb beers tonight:
13 - Nick's AIPA
As others have said, looks dark but drinks with a great body. Smells of passionfruit, mango and melon - bit of Mosaic in there? Slight hint of burnt toffee, but nothing close to cloying and it matches brilliantly with the superb, hyperbolic bitterness. Seriously impressive bitterness: firm but balanced, long-lasting, and builds to a woodier bitterness with more frequent sips - as one is prone to do with a beer like this.
Although I like more of the mid-range/toastier malts in IPA's, this is a stellar example of an AIPA - job very well done.
11 - Fattox's cherrywood smoked FES
Black, ruby highlights, a dark brown head, and heavy on the drinking arm - a sign of a good stout. Or it could be that I've climbed far too many ladders today...
Smell is pretty subdued, with chocolate there and a slight smokiness - not a bacon smoke though.
Taste is wonderful - beautiful smoke is there from the initial sip to the lasting finish, with caramel and chocolate in there too.
Very very minor tartness in the finish from the roasted malts - what was your water chemistry like?
How did you do the cherrywood smoking - a kg or so of the pale over the wood smoke? The beer is fantastic - a wonderful stout with a unique depth of smoke, well done.