I went - not too bad. As people said, it got crowded after a while, but not so bad you couldn't get a beer. We got there at 4:25 and had a ticket in our hand 30secs after they started selling... things were fairly civilized for the first 60mins or so then it started to get busy, but I had done the majority of what I wanted by then anyway.
Wanted to taste breweries I had either not tasted before, or only once. Then after I had done that, new beers from older hands.
Set targets for:
Bellarine Brewing - Queenscliff Ale v'good - Mussel stout pretty damn good - Lonsdale lager quite good - rest... not so good
Effen Brewing - One beer - and despite hating the marketing angle they are taking, its a good one. Nothing earth shattering but a solid euro style lager. Like a slightly lighter bodied Peroni.
Hawthorn Brewing Co - just a Pale ale. Its a good one. A really balanced beer with a remarkable even palate. There was maltiness, hoppiness and good body... but all very very balanced and even with none of the flavours or aromas sticking out or dominating. You could call it boring... but I call it drinkable and superbly constructed. Maybe a touch astringent if you want to be fussy.
Sweetwater Brewing - 4 beers, rock solid. Nothing to blow your socks off, but a set of four I would happily sit down to drink any old day. The Golden Bitter was the best of them IMO
Three Troupers - A Pale and a Pilsner, neither of which I would really bother with if there were other choices. Not bad, but not what I would call good either.
Arctic Fox - I had tried the lager before and it was a nasty nasty train wreck of a beer. Its not any more... now its just averagely unpleasant instead of truly horrible. The Pale ale is slightly less bad.
And apart from that it was new beers from more familiar brewers.
Fourstar pointed me to the Bright Brewery Lager ... Fourstar - you are a *******. That beer beats out Arctic fox as the number one worst beer i have ever had. It was truly lousy and I tipped it out.. forced to go to Three Ravens for a good beer to make the horrible aftertaste go away.
Otway estate - sorry, but I tried two more of them and still haven't had a good beer from this brewery.
Holgate Nut brown - well and truly up to their usual High standard
Redhill Baltic Porter - a Grand beer. Smooth smooth smooth
3 Ravens - got the last 4 or 5 of my tickets. Their Bourbon Barrel ale was delicious. Too much bourbon and too much oak... but damn it was nice anyway. And all their other beer is as usual superb.
I was a little disappointed really - more than half the new beers I tried were at best mediocre in quality; and at worst really called into question the brewer's ability to actually tell what is a good beer, let alone brew one. And this lack of quality was only underlined by the absolutely beautiful beers that some of the other brewers, especially some of the more established operations, were presenting.