Vic Xmas 2009 Case Swap - Tasting Thread

[brendo]

I'll happily go through the exercise of scoring/commenting on beers as per BJCP - good practice for the exam next year (top idea Maple) and happy to provide that level of detail to those who want it.

Also happy to hear the good, bad and ugly on my contribution - afterall that is one of the reason I participate in these things.

So it looks like the current list is:

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo

 

[zebba]

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba

I went in this to learn stuff, not to get circle-jerked. Although that was fun Saturday night also

(Edit: Added Brendo)

 

[Fents]

no score for me pls fella's i know where my beers at dont need 15 others confirming it for me.

 

[Hutch]

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba
Hutch

Yep, I'll join in as well. Only issue is that I can't quite pidgeon-hole my beer in a specific style category.
I'd categorise it as a new-world German Pilsner (ie. German pils brewed with NZ hops).
BJCP category 18.7 - "Other Specialty".

 

[Supra-Jim]

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba
Hutch
Supra-Jim

I been canned before, and can probably handle it again, bring it on!!

Cheers SJ

edit: I actually have a very fragile ego and am currently experiencing a rare moment of bravado! :wacko:

 

[gava]

I would like mine reviewed and abused...

 

[seemax]

sounds good to me, i must be brave I haven't even sampled my beer yet !!

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba
Hutch
Supra-Jim
Seemax

 

[Hutch]

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba
Hutch
Supra-Jim
Seemax
gava

 

[Leigh]

sounds good to me, i must be brave I haven't even sampled my beer yet !!

Haven't sampled mine yet either h34r:

But I'm confident that I'll get a positive result (I don't think you can get a score below 0 under BJCP)

 

[Leigh]

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba
Hutch
Supra-Jim
Seemax
gava
cm2
4*

Afterall, 'tis only fair that they cop a baggin' too if they are baggin' us

 

[Maple]

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba
Hutch
Supra-Jim
Seemax
gava
cm2
4*

Afterall, 'tis only fair that they cop a baggin' too if they are baggin' us

Don't think CM2 will be doing all that much reviewing, but up to him if he wants in. kleiny and shit-hot-brewerChris should be in though...

 

[Fourstar]

Yeah of course i'll be in!

To reduce bias in judging, should we all hold off on giving the scores out until everyone judging has scored the beer or just go nuts?!?

 

[Wonderwoman]

I'd be interested to get a score on my beer ...and I think I can handle criticism

 

[Fourstar]

And the prize you get for best of swap?!?!

You have to provide the recipe. :icon_chickcheers:

 

[therook]

And the prize you get for best of swap?!?!

You have to provide the recipe. :icon_chickcheers:

You get to chew on a pair of Barra's Undies :icon_cheers:

Rook

 

[Fents]

speaking of did Mr Barra make it to the swap?

 

[Fourstar]

You get to chew on a pair of Barra's Undies :icon_cheers:

Rook

Isn't that the reason why you couldn't make the swap Rooky? :icon_vomit:

:lol:

 

[scott_penno]

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba
Hutch
Supra-Jim
Seemax
gava
cm2
4*
sappas

 

[Kleiny]

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba
Hutch
Supra-Jim
Seemax
gava
cm2
4*
sappas
Kleiny

Happy to score and be scorned

Hay rook the Banana Flu didnt kill you :lol:

 

[Wonderwoman]

oops... forgot to put my nme on the list

Maple
Warmbeer
Manticle
Leigh
Brendo
Zebba
Hutch
Supra-Jim
Seemax
gava
cm2
4*
sappas
Kleiny
Wonderwoman