rafinus said:Hi guys, first at all, thanks Lael for the updates and the work...
Now I´m design my vessel and the malt pipe to make 40 liters and 20 liters of beer (final). But I have a problem of space in my house (department) then using the sheet of Braumeister Calculation, the diameter of main vessel for this application is 45cm and 65cm height. The diameter of malt pipe for 40l is 35cm and the height is 60cm. To 20l, is 35cm diameter and 35 height. I assume that i´ll use max 8kg of malt in 20l and 12kg for 40l.
Now my question, any consideration or opinions?
PS: I have a friend that will made the vessel/pipes in stainless steel.
Thanks a lot.
lael said:Hi Judanero,
Your sizes have some problems. I'm going to post a spreadsheet I modelled for you based on the rough sizes you gave. If you have the ability to do custom pot sizes, then I think the dimensions on the sheet I am posting (shorter 20L pipe and 40L pipe) are better as they allow your fluid levels to work more effectively. I think what I've posted is probably my ideal sizing, but I couldn't get custom pots
http://aussiehomebrewer.com/topic/57924-braumeister-nextgen-build/page-56#entry1023693
rafinus said:Hi Lael, thanks. The exactly the same size I planned, maybe the malt pipe for 20l is 5cm tall...
Thanks
Rafael
You can still do it with 5cm higher malt pipes, you are just running out of sparge water. in the case of a 1040 beer, it might mean that you throw more grain in, and end up with 25L/ 30L instead of 20L. or just waste a few hundred grams of grain (to increase the sugars in the wort to compensate for the sugar that is retained because you don't sparge.... Not the worst thing in the world.rafinus said:Thanks for the tips Lael,
Yeah I note that before, its a clone, hehe. Well, I assume that the BM is not so effective for high EG (or i´m wrong). But now I realized that I´ll not produce 50L but 40L, because my room and keg´s availability.
My project is better if I can show, the dimensions here (in green):
How you can see, the exclusions for the filters its around 7cm.
For the elements I´ll planning to use a 4000w (with 2 turns), and 10cm from de botton or 5cm (i think 5cm is better). In Brazil we can adjust the wire for this with no problems.
The heating element to customize here is around USD 80,00. The most expensive thing is the stainless filters. USD 200,00 each, but I looking for alternatives.
Attached the sheet with my sizes. I worried about the max grain bill can I use for 40l is only 11kg, and for 20l is only 4,7kg. Now if I change the malt pipes height and put 5cm more, the min water is too big. Any tip?
Thanks for the help.
Rafael - Braumiser_Volume_ScenarioTester.xls
The minimum water for the grain bill relies upon two calculations. The first one is - how much water fits in the malt pipe? (col J - we need to make it overflow) and how much water do we need to cover the heating element (col A multiplied by col O). Add those two together and you have the minimum water level.rafinus said:Understood, but how about the min water? Don´t compromise?
Thanks,
Lael, thanks for the reply.lael said:The minimum water for the grain bill relies upon two calculations. The first one is - how much water fits in the malt pipe? (col J - we need to make it overflow) and how much water do we need to cover the heating element (col A multiplied by col O). Add those two together and you have the minimum water level.
The water is pumped out of the outside pipe, lowering the water level, and into the malt pipe, raising the water level, until the water overflows out of the malt pipe. If you don't put in enough water - your heating element will be exposed when you start pumping water through the malt pipe during mashing. That will destroy a lot of heating elements (not good. some can handle being boiled dry, but generally have a longer life it they aren't). If you don't put enough water in, there may not be enough to oveflow the malt pipe, which means you get no recirculation. Have you seen a braumeister in action? I can post a youtube video of my clone working if you want?
The only way to save water there, is to reduce the height of the element from the base of the outside pot. At the moment it is set at 10cm, as a lot of diy heating elements have a minimum no-bend zone, meaning it is hard to get the heating element lower, unless you pay for a custom element to be bent for you. If you can do that (I think bigbanko did that with his) then you might be able to get as low as 4cm min water height (first column on the spreadsheet), which would allow you to reduce you minimum water to allow safe recirculation (without exposing the element) by about three litres. That gives you a little more sparge water to play with (which allows you to sparge the grain with more water after you remove the malt pipe, which extracts more sugar from it and gives you higher efficiency (more sugar out of the same grain).
Have you brewed all grain before? I hadn't and had trouble working out why all the numbers were important too.
So the short of the answer is - if you reduce the minimum water level without either changing the malt pipe size (to require less water) or lower the heating element (also means you need less water) then you will be in trouble.
The other thing that is slightly counter-intuitive, but interesting is that grain displaces volume in the malt pipe (from memory it is something like 1.6L, but it absorbs about a L per kg of grain, so actual displacement is about .65L (col C)) which means that the larger the grain bill, the less water you need to overflow the malt pipe and get your element covered with water. Which is why I was saying with smaller grain bills (like 3kg or so for a 1040 beer) you can simply up the grain bill, and increase the volume of beer you produce (eg: make a 30L batch rather than a 20L batch) (unless you are using kegs and are anal about not getting left over beer to bottle ).
Does that help explain how it works a little more?
lael said:Hi All, updates below:
rafinus - 1 - paid
Stux - 1 - paid - posted
nickelass - 1 - paid
mattieharding - 1 - paid - posted
DavidP2190 -1 - paid - posted
judanero - 1 - paid - posted
Kezza - 1 - paid - posted
Ramps - 2 - paid - send me your address please?
barrel21 -1 - paid - posted
lachw - 1 - paid - posted
heavy-d - 1 - paid - posted
pat_00 - 1 - paid - posted
zburns - 2 - paid - posted
stevemc32 - 1 - paid - posted
mfleck - 1 - paid - posted
djar007 - 1 - send me your address please?
cosmic bertie - 1 - paid - posted
If anyone else wants in - just PM me and I'll see what I can do.
Enter your email address to join: