mika
Lupulin Threshold Shift Victim
- Joined
- 6/11/05
- Messages
- 2,990
- Reaction score
- 6
Sandgroper Christmas Case 2006 Consumption
- Thread starter Guest Lurker
- Start date
Help Support Australia & New Zealand Homebrewing Forum:
Hillbilly
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 8/9/05
- Messages
- 66
- Reaction score
- 0
Sat outside with my wife tonight with another crack @ the case, this one was the Goat - Belgian Wit. Mate for me you are an absolute legend not because it is the very best of the case but because it was so different we really loved this one, thanx Goat top stuff.
The Hillbillys. :beer:
The Hillbillys. :beer:
Whistlingjack
Dipl. Braumeister VLB, Berlin
- Joined
- 19/4/06
- Messages
- 813
- Reaction score
- 8
Confession time...
Forgive me brewers, its been 10 minutes since my last beer...
I admit to drinking a large quantity of the case at a farewell BBQ with some of my friends.
All thedrinkers tasters were impressed by the quality and taste of the selection. I had full intentions of analysing each beer with the help of many sets of taste buds, but somehow the cataloging of the samples got muddled... :chug:
Seriously good beer, except for one sample which I can't remember.
Sorry about that. Two beers got evaluated in a previous post.
I hope to be in the next one, if I get home in time.
Forgive me brewers, its been 10 minutes since my last beer...
I admit to drinking a large quantity of the case at a farewell BBQ with some of my friends.
All the
Seriously good beer, except for one sample which I can't remember.
Sorry about that. Two beers got evaluated in a previous post.
I hope to be in the next one, if I get home in time.
Guest Lurker
Big Dog Brewing
- Joined
- 21/11/03
- Messages
- 2,063
- Reaction score
- 2
Chillas wheezing south african game animal
Highly carbed without being over the top. Pours with a good head that didnt hang around in my glasses. Chocolate brown colour with a hint of red. Aroma is esters and a bit of spicy alcohol. Light medium body, made lighter by the spritzy carbonation. Flavour is quite a delicate balance between banana ester, carbonic bite, alcohol warmth, slight toasty malt, maybe a little bubblegum. Everything seems to sit in its place without dominating. Wouldnt know how it goes style wise, but seems like a very well crafted beer to me, impressive, almost convinces me to make a wheat beer.
Highly carbed without being over the top. Pours with a good head that didnt hang around in my glasses. Chocolate brown colour with a hint of red. Aroma is esters and a bit of spicy alcohol. Light medium body, made lighter by the spritzy carbonation. Flavour is quite a delicate balance between banana ester, carbonic bite, alcohol warmth, slight toasty malt, maybe a little bubblegum. Everything seems to sit in its place without dominating. Wouldnt know how it goes style wise, but seems like a very well crafted beer to me, impressive, almost convinces me to make a wheat beer.
Guest Lurker
Big Dog Brewing
- Joined
- 21/11/03
- Messages
- 2,063
- Reaction score
- 2
Fletchwiezen
Bugger me, another wheaty in the case. Pours very bright, big carbonation, head retention poor, probably a function of eating smoked chorizos at the same time. Seems to have the right flavours in the right places. Crisp wheatiness, carbonic bite, restrained banana, maybe a few more phenolics in this one but I am not good at picking them. Good beer (for a wheat).
Bugger me, another wheaty in the case. Pours very bright, big carbonation, head retention poor, probably a function of eating smoked chorizos at the same time. Seems to have the right flavours in the right places. Crisp wheatiness, carbonic bite, restrained banana, maybe a few more phenolics in this one but I am not good at picking them. Good beer (for a wheat).
ausdb
Copper kettles don't kill people....
- Joined
- 21/8/04
- Messages
- 1,517
- Reaction score
- 0
Holy Sh!t GL considering brewing a wheat beer
h34r:
mika
Lupulin Threshold Shift Victim
- Joined
- 6/11/05
- Messages
- 2,990
- Reaction score
- 6
GL's Green Tea Lager
Tastes like beer, I had one of my own APA's not too long before (bit of a silly move in Hindsight) and I got nothing of the Green Tea taste coming thru, even on the second glass. Maybe just too subtle for my tastes...apart from that seemed like a good beer
Goat's Wit For Brains
Moderate carbonation for style (to my mind), cloudy to style. First tastes I got didn't indicate the Coriander and Orange Peel flavour, I thought more Nutmeg :unsure: Maybe the steeping n Vodka modified the taste a bit. Did you use fresh coriander seeds and grind them yourself ?
Their addition was probably a good thing, personally I can't taste anything else behind the Coriander/Nutmeg.
A good beer none-the-less.
Tastes like beer, I had one of my own APA's not too long before (bit of a silly move in Hindsight) and I got nothing of the Green Tea taste coming thru, even on the second glass. Maybe just too subtle for my tastes...apart from that seemed like a good beer
Goat's Wit For Brains
Moderate carbonation for style (to my mind), cloudy to style. First tastes I got didn't indicate the Coriander and Orange Peel flavour, I thought more Nutmeg :unsure: Maybe the steeping n Vodka modified the taste a bit. Did you use fresh coriander seeds and grind them yourself ?
Their addition was probably a good thing, personally I can't taste anything else behind the Coriander/Nutmeg.
A good beer none-the-less.
HillBilly's Pale
Opened it and it looked flat? Poured it and it was vigorously carbed settled down after a few minutes. Very clear beer, with a spritzy carbonation. Pretty clean taste to it no major hops jumping out, Can taste a little extract twang? Easy drinking brew this one.
ant - Strong London Ale
Drank this one a couple of weeks ago after a few warm up beers but from what I recall. Memories of Coopers vintage ale which I like. Too cool initially but nicer once warmed a little. Plenty of caramel with some choc/roast smoothness and that nice warming alcohol. Be a nice one for winter! Wouldn't mind seing the recipe for this, a strong ale is on my 2do list
Opened it and it looked flat? Poured it and it was vigorously carbed
settled down after a few minutes. Very clear beer, with a spritzy carbonation. Pretty clean taste to it no major hops jumping out, Can taste a little extract twang? Easy drinking brew this one.ant - Strong London Ale
Drank this one a couple of weeks ago after a few warm up beers but from what I recall. Memories of Coopers vintage ale which I like. Too cool initially but nicer once warmed a little. Plenty of caramel with some choc/roast smoothness and that nice warming alcohol. Be a nice one for winter! Wouldn't mind seing the recipe for this, a strong ale is on my 2do list
Guest Lurker
Big Dog Brewing
- Joined
- 21/11/03
- Messages
- 2,063
- Reaction score
- 2
Barfridges Toby
I would say keep this one a bit longer. Carbonation is Ok, but not yet clear, and head retention is average, which is OK considering 9% but I think it will improve. Also I think it may attenuate a little further in the bottle which would achive that clean crisp belgian taste. Apart from that, it is a nice Belgian beer with the right sort of flavours in the right sort of places and the alcohol very well disguised.
OK guys, I have now posted reviews for every case beer, plus an extra one that I thought was a case beer.
One of the reasons for doing the case is to get some feedback on what people think of your beer, so lets see some more reviews. Doesnt have to be BJCP sanctioned descriptions, "I liked it because, or "I didnt like it because" are fine.
But let me make the point that this was a truly excellent set of beers, and there was not a single beer in the case where I would have rathered receive a commercial version, so lets all remember that next year at case time. Get involved, and dont worry too much about whether the beer is up to standard.
Cheers
Simon
I would say keep this one a bit longer. Carbonation is Ok, but not yet clear, and head retention is average, which is OK considering 9% but I think it will improve. Also I think it may attenuate a little further in the bottle which would achive that clean crisp belgian taste. Apart from that, it is a nice Belgian beer with the right sort of flavours in the right sort of places and the alcohol very well disguised.
OK guys, I have now posted reviews for every case beer, plus an extra one that I thought was a case beer.
One of the reasons for doing the case is to get some feedback on what people think of your beer, so lets see some more reviews. Doesnt have to be BJCP sanctioned descriptions, "I liked it because, or "I didnt like it because" are fine.
But let me make the point that this was a truly excellent set of beers, and there was not a single beer in the case where I would have rathered receive a commercial version, so lets all remember that next year at case time. Get involved, and dont worry too much about whether the beer is up to standard.
Cheers
Simon
Please Sir Strong London Ale (Maw Beer)
OG 1.065
FG 1.014
ABV 6.9%
IBU 52
5.5 kg Maris Otter
0.5 kg 55L Crystal (Joe White)
0.5 kg rolled wheat
400 gm rice hulls
38 gm East Kent Goldings @ 5.2% (90 min)
14 gm Fuggles @ 5.7% (75 min)
28 gm East Kent Goldings @ 5.2% (15 min)
38 gm East Kent Goldings @ 5.2% (1 min)
WY1968
Mash @ 66.7C for 90 min w. 15L water @ 75C
Sparge w. 15L water @ 75C
90 min boil down to 22L
Cooled to 21C, pitch 1.5L starter, aerate 5 minutes
Racked 20.5L to secondary after 16 days @ 1.014 (78% attenuation)
Bulk primed w 80 gm dextrose in 0.3L water (far too much for style!!!)
OG 1.065
FG 1.014
ABV 6.9%
IBU 52
5.5 kg Maris Otter
0.5 kg 55L Crystal (Joe White)
0.5 kg rolled wheat
400 gm rice hulls
38 gm East Kent Goldings @ 5.2% (90 min)
14 gm Fuggles @ 5.7% (75 min)
28 gm East Kent Goldings @ 5.2% (15 min)
38 gm East Kent Goldings @ 5.2% (1 min)
WY1968
Mash @ 66.7C for 90 min w. 15L water @ 75C
Sparge w. 15L water @ 75C
90 min boil down to 22L
Cooled to 21C, pitch 1.5L starter, aerate 5 minutes
Racked 20.5L to secondary after 16 days @ 1.014 (78% attenuation)
Bulk primed w 80 gm dextrose in 0.3L water (far too much for style!!!)
deebee
The Bludgeon Brewery
- Joined
- 12/6/03
- Messages
- 1,174
- Reaction score
- 0
Ashs Bavarian Surprise
Lovely honey amber tones, a billowing off-white head and an instant whiff of hops, even at the icy temp I poured it at. Knowing nothing about the recipe, I would describe it as a well-hopped lager towards the bitter side with big hops aroma and flavour, especially as it warmed up. A specialty malt seems large in the finish but it doesn't come over as sweet. I found the bitternss a little too big, but overall, a well-brewed beer.
Hillbilly
The clearest and brightest beer in the pack. Light to medium bodied with straight up malt profile, little hops presence and a satisfying dry finish. Very highly carbed: climbing out of the glass. Some slightly untidy flavours from fermentation temperature or sanitation, but drinking fine at this stage. I would keep an eye on the carbonation in case of bombs.
Lovely honey amber tones, a billowing off-white head and an instant whiff of hops, even at the icy temp I poured it at. Knowing nothing about the recipe, I would describe it as a well-hopped lager towards the bitter side with big hops aroma and flavour, especially as it warmed up. A specialty malt seems large in the finish but it doesn't come over as sweet. I found the bitternss a little too big, but overall, a well-brewed beer.
Hillbilly
The clearest and brightest beer in the pack. Light to medium bodied with straight up malt profile, little hops presence and a satisfying dry finish. Very highly carbed: climbing out of the glass. Some slightly untidy flavours from fermentation temperature or sanitation, but drinking fine at this stage. I would keep an eye on the carbonation in case of bombs.
Vlad the Pale Aler
Cereal Killer
- Joined
- 7/3/04
- Messages
- 1,146
- Reaction score
- 3
aye aye cap'n
Fallen angel bo pils
Read the BJCP guidelines for this one, cos that is what you get. I would be surprised at anything less from the Junctyard.
Wit for brains
Its a while since I 've had a Wit, and after this one I should revisit the style soon. All the spicy notes in the right place that set it apart from the German wheats, refreshing to the last drop.
Wheezing Bock
Great label, and a beer to match. Had one of Jeffs bocks before and this is a refinement of the process, nice colour, well carbonated to style, alcohol warming may be a little out of place but will mellow. Time to start entering comps Jeff.
Jason Y APA
Poured out to reveal a massive rocky white head out of character for the style but very pleasing on the eye, and it stayed for the end of the beer.
Not much hops on the nose but made up for in the taste, huge aggresive citrus hops up front that decimate the pallate for any later malt, very satisfying and one for the hop heads.
Roger Mellie Summer Ale
Nice pour , restrained carbonation, subtle well formed head. Citrus hops seem to dominate and come though to the finish, but there is something else there, probably the Nelson Sauvin which I am not familiar with, a sort of mint herb aromatic thing. The malt is balanced well with the hop, but slightly more toward the hop which is fine with me. This could be a classic with a bit of tweaking.
Ash's Bavarian Surprise
Mrs. Vlad is the wheat beer afficianado of the family, and gave it the claws up, which is a compliment.
Unidentified wheat beer
The bottle has a Ren or Stimpy character sucking on a bottle, sorry I can't identify where it came from.
The beer itself is a dunkel weisse, and a good one to boot. Plenty of body, the aromas lasting through as was the fine thick head, whatever it was it was a good one.
Fallen angel bo pils
Read the BJCP guidelines for this one, cos that is what you get. I would be surprised at anything less from the Junctyard.
Wit for brains
Its a while since I 've had a Wit, and after this one I should revisit the style soon. All the spicy notes in the right place that set it apart from the German wheats, refreshing to the last drop.
Wheezing Bock
Great label, and a beer to match. Had one of Jeffs bocks before and this is a refinement of the process, nice colour, well carbonated to style, alcohol warming may be a little out of place but will mellow. Time to start entering comps Jeff.
Jason Y APA
Poured out to reveal a massive rocky white head out of character for the style but very pleasing on the eye, and it stayed for the end of the beer.
Not much hops on the nose but made up for in the taste, huge aggresive citrus hops up front that decimate the pallate for any later malt, very satisfying and one for the hop heads.
Roger Mellie Summer Ale
Nice pour , restrained carbonation, subtle well formed head. Citrus hops seem to dominate and come though to the finish, but there is something else there, probably the Nelson Sauvin which I am not familiar with, a sort of mint herb aromatic thing. The malt is balanced well with the hop, but slightly more toward the hop which is fine with me. This could be a classic with a bit of tweaking.
Ash's Bavarian Surprise
Mrs. Vlad is the wheat beer afficianado of the family, and gave it the claws up, which is a compliment.
Unidentified wheat beer
The bottle has a Ren or Stimpy character sucking on a bottle, sorry I can't identify where it came from.
The beer itself is a dunkel weisse, and a good one to boot. Plenty of body, the aromas lasting through as was the fine thick head, whatever it was it was a good one.
Ash's Bavarian Surprise slipped down and was popular with the pool players, which on a Friday night is the ultimate aim. Personally I detected an earthy flavour at the finish which I was unsure of and whose absence I would have preferred. Perhaps someone can tell me why it was there.
Whistling Jack's Hefeweizen was not as popular. The brew was well constructed in that it was just like the first blonde I took out--well built, a good lively lasting head and had a great mouthfeel, but no personality. I think that like the blonde, it should have been trotted out a little earlier when everything was new and wonderful.
Whistling Jack's Hefeweizen was not as popular. The brew was well constructed in that it was just like the first blonde I took out--well built, a good lively lasting head and had a great mouthfeel, but no personality. I think that like the blonde, it should have been trotted out a little earlier when everything was new and wonderful.
Vlad - Transylvanian Pale Ale
Cloudy and light on carbonation. Plenty of hop flavour and complexity, some chalkiness - lots of gypsum maybe? Nice ale.
Simon W - Hopburst Amber Ale
A good enjoyable beer. Lightly carbonated, virtually no head, cloudy. Colour more like a pale ale. Hop flavour lower than expected but still good drinking.
Deebee - Rainy Zephyr Pale Ale
Well balanced darkish pale ale. Nice maltiness, with plenty of hops. Lovely beer.
Ant - Strong London Ale
Cloudy, medium carbonation, small head. Nice and malty, but could still taste the hops - well balanced strong ale. Noticeable alcohol flavour. Probably would have been better if I had left to mature for longer before drinking. Good beer and like your choice of style.
JasonY - APA
Nice medium carbonation, cloudy. Thin head that lasts. Nice hop flavour, typical piney/resinous American hop flavour but slightly overdone - in my opinion, but others will disagree. Everything after this tastes bland. Really enjoyed this and wanted another, but not sure my tongue will recover.
Cloudy and light on carbonation. Plenty of hop flavour and complexity, some chalkiness - lots of gypsum maybe? Nice ale.
Simon W - Hopburst Amber Ale
A good enjoyable beer. Lightly carbonated, virtually no head, cloudy. Colour more like a pale ale. Hop flavour lower than expected but still good drinking.
Deebee - Rainy Zephyr Pale Ale
Well balanced darkish pale ale. Nice maltiness, with plenty of hops. Lovely beer.
Ant - Strong London Ale
Cloudy, medium carbonation, small head. Nice and malty, but could still taste the hops - well balanced strong ale. Noticeable alcohol flavour. Probably would have been better if I had left to mature for longer before drinking. Good beer and like your choice of style.
JasonY - APA
Nice medium carbonation, cloudy. Thin head that lasts. Nice hop flavour, typical piney/resinous American hop flavour but slightly overdone - in my opinion, but others will disagree. Everything after this tastes bland. Really enjoyed this and wanted another, but not sure my tongue will recover.
mika
Lupulin Threshold Shift Victim
- Joined
- 6/11/05
- Messages
- 2,990
- Reaction score
- 6
Rainy Zephyr Pale Ale
No offence but my bottle of the beer seemed to be really watery. Almost no flavour at all. Maybe I got a dud bottle :unsure:
Marlboro Bock
Only a light 'pfft' on opening, but it tried to climb out of the glass when pouring....I got really good mileage out of this one. Whiff of Banana at the same time, and it certainly tasted very Estery.
I know the Bock is an aquired taste and I must admit to never having tasted a true Bock, but to me this one seemed like it wasn't done cooking. I can't describe the taste any better than that... it's probably just me.
Shotgun Pale Ale
I can read the post's on AHB thru this ! How did you get it so clear ?
This also tried to climb out of the glass as I poured, yet the head, by the time I'm half way down the glass, is almost non-existent. I'm getting almost like a smoke flavour to the beer ?
Easy to drink, but for my personal taste it needs a more dominant malt or hop flavour to make it stand out
Santa's Saaz B Lager
The bottle's empty so I must have drunk it, but I have no idea what it was like :blink:
No offence but my bottle of the beer seemed to be really watery. Almost no flavour at all. Maybe I got a dud bottle :unsure:
Marlboro Bock
Only a light 'pfft' on opening, but it tried to climb out of the glass when pouring....I got really good mileage out of this one. Whiff of Banana at the same time, and it certainly tasted very Estery.
I know the Bock is an aquired taste and I must admit to never having tasted a true Bock, but to me this one seemed like it wasn't done cooking. I can't describe the taste any better than that... it's probably just me.
Shotgun Pale Ale
I can read the post's on AHB thru this ! How did you get it so clear ?
This also tried to climb out of the glass as I poured, yet the head, by the time I'm half way down the glass, is almost non-existent. I'm getting almost like a smoke flavour to the beer ?
Easy to drink, but for my personal taste it needs a more dominant malt or hop flavour to make it stand out
Santa's Saaz B Lager
The bottle's empty so I must have drunk it, but I have no idea what it was like :blink:
Asher
Junctyard Brewing
- Joined
- 27/1/04
- Messages
- 958
- Reaction score
- 4
Now the new year has arrived I'm hoping for some time to sit down and enjoy some of the case..... First up was Goat's 'Wit for brains'
Vanilla flavours and orange oil. A very nice wit. I believe there was some bottle tampering involved in this beer... What ever it was it adds a great complexity to a style that I have been finding hard to appreciate of late. Very tasty
Vanilla flavours and orange oil. A very nice wit. I believe there was some bottle tampering involved in this beer... What ever it was it adds a great complexity to a style that I have been finding hard to appreciate of late. Very tasty
chillamacgilla73
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 8/12/04
- Messages
- 296
- Reaction score
- 1
Some of these my tastings are a little 'foggy' from too much christmas cheer...
Deebee - Rainy Zephyr Pale Ale
Shared this as an aperitif for the traditional New Years Day webber luncheon with the family. Well balanced with decent carbonation, darkish colour, small head that didn't dissappear, big malt flavour and hops that are a little light on but still there. We raised a toast to Rainy and sent your family good healing thoughts.
Ant - Strong London Ale
Not too carbonated, nice crystal aroma(?), a great balance of full flavour malty crystal, hops and warming alcohol. I am not experienced with the style other than the coopers drop and enjoyed this beer very much and may have to have a crack at the style sometime.
Simon W - Hopburst Amber Ale
Prepared myself for the worse after Simon slipped the boot into his brew on a previous post! Low carbonation and hop aroma, a little light in colour and a touch cloudy(Prob my clumsy pour!), light on in the hop department but malt flavour present, still a very enjoyable beer that slid down on a balmy twilight.
All beers have been top notch and a credit to the brewer.
Cheers
Deebee - Rainy Zephyr Pale Ale
Shared this as an aperitif for the traditional New Years Day webber luncheon with the family. Well balanced with decent carbonation, darkish colour, small head that didn't dissappear, big malt flavour and hops that are a little light on but still there. We raised a toast to Rainy and sent your family good healing thoughts.
Ant - Strong London Ale
Not too carbonated, nice crystal aroma(?), a great balance of full flavour malty crystal, hops and warming alcohol. I am not experienced with the style other than the coopers drop and enjoyed this beer very much and may have to have a crack at the style sometime.
Simon W - Hopburst Amber Ale
Prepared myself for the worse after Simon slipped the boot into his brew on a previous post! Low carbonation and hop aroma, a little light in colour and a touch cloudy(Prob my clumsy pour!), light on in the hop department but malt flavour present, still a very enjoyable beer that slid down on a balmy twilight.
All beers have been top notch and a credit to the brewer.
Cheers
facter
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 19/2/05
- Messages
- 246
- Reaction score
- 0
sounds like my Fletchweizen I think? the dude on the pic was definately sucking on a beer bottle
hahahadont tihnk anyone else had a label like that! If its mine, thanks
... hefe's are my favorite so its always nice when one turns out well.Im going to post all my notes together from this point on! So give me another week or so (well, for all except the heavy ones, im going to let them go a while longer)
Hillbilly
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 8/9/05
- Messages
- 66
- Reaction score
- 0
Not sure what went wrong with the carbonation, bulk primed with 160 grams of dextrose, must say it's been a year and a half since i've bottled ( go the kegs! ). Might be a good thing to drink my one a few minutes after opening, bugger, sorry guys.
Hillbilly. :unsure:
Hillbilly. :unsure:
Hillbilly
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 8/9/05
- Messages
- 66
- Reaction score
- 0
Golden Harvest.
Heavy roast flavor at the start, bit over powering, but a few sips later it's like it blends in a bit more, perfect carbonation, great lace. As I've lived most my life in Holland I could see myself enjoying a few of these on a cold winter night.
Asher.
Nice creamy head, great carbonation perfect hop balance, can't add anything else but a top drop.
9 out of 10 for me. Great stuff.
Heavy roast flavor at the start, bit over powering, but a few sips later it's like it blends in a bit more, perfect carbonation, great lace. As I've lived most my life in Holland I could see myself enjoying a few of these on a cold winter night.
Asher.
Nice creamy head, great carbonation perfect hop balance, can't add anything else but a top drop.
9 out of 10 for me. Great stuff.
Similar threads
