It's been a while, so I thought i'd make it worthwhile
Battle of the Tripels!
Westmalle Trappist Trippel vs Tripel Karmaliet
Both amazing beers.
Both of which i've tried many times before
Both are serious contenders to being the best Tripels in the world.
So a side by side comparison certainly would be nice...
But i'm not content with that...
The twist?
Both are 5 years past their Best Before!
Results?
The Karmaliet had obvious signs of oxidation from the word go; browned "apple juice" sort of colour, no head retention, low carbonation. Yet the flavour was still deeply complex with lots of phenolic spice and rich bready malt, with the sherry-like undertones of an old beer.
The Westmalle...words can't explain how well this beer aged! It had hardly changed...more than 5 years down the track! Stunning golden beer that holds a big dense white head that still retains the unbelievably complex spicy, floral, somewhat cheesy aroma, with a rich velvety and beautifully balanced palated packed full of seemingly untainted benchmark Tripel characters with an amazingly clean finish for such an old beer.
No contest really!
Having said that, my thoughts lead me to believe the Karmaliet may have seen some harsher days than the Westmalle, storagewise, because fresh they are very comparable beer.