Pumpy,
It sounds like the switch isn't turning off. at all. Correct?
Going back to basics - is the controller plugged in to the mains power and the fridge plugged into the controller?
Did the fridge work properly before the temp controller was added?
Was the fridge very cold and had to be set to middle calibration to keep things at the right temp?
Or was the fridge a new unit (to your house), and you have no knowledge of settings when used as a straight kitchen fridge?
If you set the fridge internal thermostat to mid range, then see if the controller works. If not, U could reasonably blame the controller.
I'd also try the controller at about 5 degrees below room temp, and see if the switch cuts out. when it reaches the target temp.
See how U go and report back.
Seth