I made one on the weekend just gone. It's a repeat of the recipe I made 12 months ago which was tops. Silky smooth, heaps of flavour and a killer head on every glass. Last time I held the RB back until 15mins before the end of the mash, this time it went in at the start. I'm not anticipating a lot of difference. I'll use malted oats next time as my LHBS will have them in stock soon.
I think the important bits in an Oatmeal stout are:
- Oats (kind of obvious)
- An English ale yeast, ferment it coolish to restrict the esters
- Bittering hops only, use an English or neutral variety
- A good hit of RB - it's not a stout without plenty of RB
- Plenty of specialty malts for complexity. I disagree with you beers, chocolate malt should be in because it's awesome.
- High mash temp to balance the drying effect of all the dark grains.
Here is the recipe I used on Saturday:
77% IMC Pale Malt
8% Uncle Toby's Quick Oats
6% Pale Choc Malt
5% Roast Barley
4% Dark English Crystal
Mash at 68 for 60min to 1.050
60min boil
NZ Goldings flowers at 60min to 30 IBUs
Wyeast 1469 from slurry at 19 deg for 2 weeks