I'm no marketing guru, but I get around this and other craft beer sites a bit as well as meeting my fair share of other craft beer appreciators across this country. I have noticed that a lot of home brewers/craft brewers tend to name their beers... I do it myself; I don't say 'schooey's hefe' or 'brass knuckle hefe'... I call it Shazzam Hefe.... Bitchslap IIPA, 8 Ball Stout, Choklat Soldya porter ...blah blah blah
It's part of an idetifier with the market you are pitching to, I guess. You give a bad arse beer a bad arse name. A controversial type beer has a controversial name. I see the Murray's beers mentioned here previously and they are a perfect example. I hardly hear anyone say Murray's American Wheat; they always say Murray's Whale... same for the Icon, P&J, punked Monk et al..
We, as our unique little group of craft beer afficianados and craft beer/homebrew producers (depending which terminology you prefer), are a fickle bunch to please, but are a piss in the ocean of the beer consuming market. Sometimes things we don't appreciate or totally agree with may hit the nail on the head with the masses, but make us turn our noses up... at the end of the day, regardless of what 0.0004% of your target market think, you need to market at your audience of best return.
My thoughts; I reckon the labels may be a bit clumsy looking, but the tagline of each title will stick in the heads and become a little 'trendier' to the audience they are pitching at.
On a side note, I had some JS Amber off tap at the Novotel at Homebush last week and noticed a significant malty-nuttiness that I thought had been lost a little while ago, tho I haven't tried it in the bottle lately. I really enjoyed it and recall at the time thinking I would seek it out again