"Cloning"
<Mini Rant:>
Typical scenario:
My Post Number 3, HI I'm a noob and picking up my fermenter vat thingo tomorrow and really love Pilsner Urquell and about to clone it - do you have a good exact kit recipe, I was told that a Brewcraft........
Now, I've been a Kit n Kilo man myself and still buy kits for my partial that I make. however I gleaned enough beer making information early on to realise that the correct answer to the above request would be:
Buy several hectares of property in the Czech Republic with a well that provides water of the following specifications: After building a very large brewery with underground vaults and constructing very large pitch lined fermenting and lagering tanks...and after a hundred and fifty years of experience and tradition, take some Bohemian malts and start with the following decoction mash......
Not knocking beginning brewers, we have all been there, but look at it this way, if we were a vintage car club forum not a brewing forum and a new member said something like "I have just bought a second hand Hyundai Excel and would like any plans or patterns for converting it into a 1938 Mercedes Staff Car replica...." the longer serving members would guide us tenderly away from that idea.
So my reply to the 'clone' enquiries would be " look, until you have mastered the basics and produced a few beers that you enjoy - kit or otherwise - you will find it difficult to emulate (not clone) those beers you aspire to. By the time you have acquired that knowledge and skill you will appreciate that your backyard operation is, at the end of the day, not going to produce exactly the same beer that is crafted in multi million dollar breweries, some of them with centuries of tradition and skills and nowadays populated by staff who have studied brewing at universities and many of whom have developed their skills in fine breweries such as Weinsteinstephan ...(sp?)
However at the end of the day you may produce something approximating to that style and may even hit on a recipe that emulates it quite well, but just for now little grasshopper a can of goop and a packet of BE2 ain't going to cut it."
Look, not being snobbish... I'm only ten percent down the track myself and I know it ... but I think we are not doing any favour to new brewers by hinting that the great beers of the world are only a can opener away. There's a difference between telling them what we think they would like to hear, and being realistic. My 2c.
</ mini rant>
Hey j1gsaw, that wasn't aimed at you or trying to burst your bubble, nothing of the sort, just a general rant that's been building up for a while ... Obvioulsy you are keen to progress beyond kits, and if you want to emulate UK beer STYLES you can certainly get up to that level but will first need to get a bit of practice in mashing, (partials or all grain), the use of the different UK hops and what they can do for you, the yeasts, etc etc and in that department you will get all the assistance you will need on the forum here. :icon_cheers:
You have actually gone in the right direction by tasting a beer that you like so that you know what it is you are aiming for. Next step is to find out how to decipher a recipe and formulate a brew that heads in that direction, a good source of info being S.B's post above.