I did one last year with over-ripe 2nds Pink Lady apples, juiced and US-05. Man it was rocket fuel, but really nice.
Did a champagne cider with Rocklea Market direct GS & Jonathan before that.
I compared it with the ALDI cider and yeah, much more character - not just the pink lady (though my preference would have been for Granny Smith, but I grabbed what was available), I could put my finger on what else but there was something extra.
The ALDI cider was good - tricked up in CC with a couple kg of frozen raspberries and then kegged to avoid fermentation. Tasty.
TBH - the over-ripeness of the Pink Ladies not only yielded better efficiency, but I reckon it just works. And I was paying 19c/kg, as opposed to around $1 per kg.
This year, now I'm in Tassie, I'll be raiding the trees on the side of the road. I'm not sure how to tell whether they're ready (most trees are now starting to drop apples, so I reckon it's time). Half will be cider with Windsor and half will become apple brandy.
Goomba