Excuse me, pulling up a six year old thread here.
Have not brewed for sometime, could pull out some excuses such as we really are spoilt for choice for really great beer nowadays but really its more I have been way too slack.
Anyway inspired by what I would call one of the countrys finest beers Steam Exchange truffles I am gunna put this one down.
I came across one thread on the northern brewer forum which denny is involved in which goes for 74 pages, only half way through the thread and found some tid bits.
Firstly the recipe which was first posted all over the net is wrong, this recipe in which doc and TDA used here was intially posted as using .5lbs of choc, now many people have brewed it this way and many have said it was the best beer they have brewed but denny came out sometime ago and said sorry that should read 1.25lbs. Another mix up on his part seems to be he mentions the brown malt is a must in this beer but later in the thread states he can't be sure which malt he actualy used wether it was an american brown malt or the bairds, he also states that it may have in fact been bairds amber :unsure:
Bairds have both amber and brown but in the same thread it is mentioned by some that sometimes bairds is sold over there as bairds brown malt with amber in brackets, getting confused yet?
by Denny Fri Sep 30, 2005 10:33 am
Thanks for the memory jog, Kris. I think maybe the "brown" I used would have been Baird amber. I just wish my notes were better back in those days.
Damn...this is interesting...
It appears the correct amount of chocolate malt for the BVIP IS 1.25 lb. for 5 gal.
The recipe that's been posted on the internet came from a Promash file on my computer here at the studio. I've checked the file and indeed it says .5 lb. But I also keep notes in a spiral notebook for every batch, so I went over them last night. Every single batch I've made used chocolate malt at a rate of 1.25 lb. for 5 gal.! So, for those who used .5 lb., I'm glad it turned out well and you liked it. For those that haven't brewed it yet and want the "original recipe", go with 1.25 lb. per 5 gal.
I may end up half and half brown and amber, we will see. There is proberly more info to come on that matter in the 74 pages of posts on northern brewer.
Anyway that part is no drama, what is of concern is the crystal malt. Most very light -light crystal malt here is quite a different beast to that used in these big american microbrewed beers and I am left thinking I don't really care much for the JWM caramalt being I have found it overly cloying even used at only half as much as this recipe calls for, I disliked that malt so much I actually threw out what I had left after I brewed a beer with it so I am not to sure about giving it another chance. But being doc and TDA used it and were more then happy with the beer I may be talked into it.
Anyway being someone who does not brew with this much crystal malt at all ussually I thought I'd ask the question here, what light crystal malts for a imperial porter you think?
My intial thoughts are use a medium at a lesser amount but thought I might aswell come here and chat about it.
Carared maybe an option but has anyone used it up around 10% in such a big beer?
Secondly anyone brewed this beer lately or at all?
thirdly I have gained some ideas about how gareth does it at steam exchange but he has been a little protective of his recipe which is fair enough, I have a feeling he uses oak aswell but ussually I end up too pissed to remember anything everytime I have spoken to gareth about his recipes.
The bourbon in his is well balanced and you could be forgiven for not picking it but I will say the vanilla flavour is the best vanilla flavour I have found in anything ever and is fairly pronounced, more so then I expect the intended slight vanilla oak barrel style subtleness that maybe was originally intended by denny but I find it an obsolutely fantastic beer, its not just a beer its a experience that stays with you for days/weeks after drinking it.
So yeah umm!
Cheers
Jayse