Great thread Wolfy :icon_cheers:
I was on the beta team of BeerSmith2 and there's a few things I'd like to say...
1. The first is that Brad Smith is very dedicated and that
is very important.
2. I think he gets hammered with suggestions / corrections and it is only the squeakiest wheel that he can pay attention to. (I also think that after a while, any program writer gets lost in minor details and can forget the major ones.)
3. BeerSmith1 actually had several major incorrect calculations. BeerSmith2 has most of these corrected but there are a few more I have noticed. They are important but not critical. (Actually, they
are critical - see my last point).
4. I never even had time to stop and consider the layout of BeerSmith2 (too busy on the things above) but I would agree with the previous posts. More tabs make the program far less transparent / useful.
5. The "brewhouse efficiency" versus ""mash efficiency" issue has been carried over to BeerSmith2 and I am surprised no one has mentioned it. Unless a user understands this issue, there is
no way they can even begin to use the program properly. See
here. Reading through this link will show how difficult it is for a new user let alone an experienced one to use the program correctly and the last part of that link hints at how many ways a new user (and experienced users) can easily go wrong.
This is, by far, the major weakness in the program - most other faults are cosmetic.
6. Every brewing program I have seen has non-existent or very lazy help. BeerSmith2 is no exception. The definitions, whilst much better than other programs are still quite ambiguous. In my opinion, help and definitions are the most important part of any program.
7. I said above that there were errors in the formulas and this was important but not critical. It
is critical though. For example, there are still errors in the hop formulae though these are better than BeerSmith1. The reason they are critical is that the only way we home brewers have of transmitting IBU information is via formulas - we cannot test every brew we do. Currently, BS2 will not scale some parts of your hop bill and the bits it does scale are not accurate. Scale it several times and the original hop bill can be quickly distorted.
...
Given the above, I think you have two choices. You can criticise BeerSmith2 or help it.
I've been roped into working on the new BIABrewer.info spreadsheet so I don't have the time to help BeerSmith2 now. I think though, that if you want to help Brad improve BeerSmith2, you really need to write on the
BeerSmith forum. Maybe it will help, maybe not?
Personally, I think his site is a real asset to the brewing community but I too, am frustrated by the above problems - more so than you can imagine.
All I can say is that posting your thoughts on the BeerSmith site might end up in a result. Posting here is a good place to gather your thoughts but unless someone posts on the BeerSmith site and others back him/her up, it will be nothing more than a gathering of thoughts...
Pat