Poor Form or Accepted ? - Entering Outside of Guidelines

[manticle]

Well I'm a cheat because I won amber dark/lager category two years in a row using an ale yeast in my alt. Alt is supposed to be an ale though so do I have to give my trophy back or what?

 

[Ducatiboy stu]

Jail term

 

[manticle]

With my pretty eyes? I wouldn't last a day.

 

[MartinOC]

Well I'm a cheat because I won amber dark/lager category two years in a row using an ale yeast in my alt. Alt is supposed to be an ale though so do I have to give my trophy back or what?

Nope! If that's the category it's in & you won, the win stands.

Believe me - there was MUCH discussion & argument within the Vicbrew committee over many, MANY years about where certain styles should fit. Sometimes we had to agree to differ.

 

[Ducatiboy stu]

Sorry Mant.....free Bed & Breakfast with lunch and dinner included and all the sex you can handle....whether you want it or not

 

[manticle]

Sounds tempting. What do I have to do again?

 

[MartinOC]

Just batt those pretty eyes of yours & let's see......(I'll make the video!)

 

[KingKong]

Mant, you will have some serious jail house cred with those drawing skills and any porn you can conjure up, not to mention jail house moonshine skills.

 

[razz]

With my pretty eyes? I wouldn't last a day.

It's not your eyes they'll go after!

 

[Toper]

Just batt those pretty eyes of yours & let's see......(I'll make the video!)

The vid's already been made :lol:

 

[dagryll]

Lots of men to ticle....

But back on topic, if someone's AWOL Kolsch trumps your Dortmunder in the lager category, you simply have to brew better beer!

 

[MartinOC]

Enter it as many times as you can, the more trophies you have the better brewer you are. :unsure:

Anyone who does that is a low-life, dirt-bag scum that deserves to be caught-out & publically flogged with birch-twigs tied-together in bundles of 5, then hung, drawn & quartered, then burned & have the ashes flushed to Werribee..

I've sort of suggested this a few times,put a 'ringer' in now and then to keep the judges on their toes.If it's done with the knowledge of the organisors it wouldn't be an issue,but if it's a fake entry it's pathetic,no joy in 'winning' by cheating.

"Knowledge without justice ought to be called cunning rather than wisdom".

Plato

 

[Ducatiboy stu]

Knowledge without justice ought to be called cunning rather than wisdom.

Plato

Its called politics

 

[QldKev]

With my pretty eyes? I wouldn't last a day.

I think they would be more interested in your pretty ass!



disclaimer: I have never actually seen manticle or his pretty ass

 

[WarmBeer]

I think they would be more interested in your pretty ass!



disclaimer: I have never actually seen manticle or his pretty ass

 

[MartinOC]

Its called politics

Not in context to what I was inferring/referring-to, but definitely an interesting spin, nonetheless.

Requires more thought......