Dont you just love that weyermanns Cara red wish I had a bag of it
Oh I do indeed!!
I realise that it was a little slack of me to never follow this thread up with results, so I guess it's better late than never.
The original recipe (5th post) I brewed posted turned out very dark, and in all ways "bigger" than the Macs, though it was an amazing beer in it's own right, and several tasters declared it the best beer they'd ever tasted. A real crowd pleaser, which was surprising based on how heavy it was. Very intense ripe stone fruit character with a faint roast note in the finish, very drinkable, though not befitting of any style so didn't do well in comps. The Nelson Sauvin definately overpowered the Motueka.
After discovering the Mac's was available commercially when I moved back to Perth I tasted thoroughly and revised my recipe, to brew the following...
80% JW Pils
10% JW Wheat
4% Cara Red
2% Cara Hell
1.5% JW Cara
1.5% JW Crystal
<1% Choc Wheat
Mashed 3L/kg at 66 (ph 5.2) to get 19L @ 1.054 into fermenter FG 1.014, dry hopped then diluted with 5L spring water to reach 4.7% abv (estimated OG/FG 1.042/1.011) or 5% carbonated.
Hopping was to 30IBU with...
20g Motueka (flowers) FWH
15g Motueka, 10g NS (pellets) 20mins
15g Motueka, 5g NS, 5g Cascade (pellets) 10 mins
15g Motueka, 5g NS, 5g Cascade (pellets) 1 mins
10g Motueka, 5g NS, 5g Cascade (pellets) DRY 5 days
Fermented with Safale S04 at 20C.
While closer in colour to the real deal, mine was definately sub-par, and while a drinkable pale ale, it was unpleasantly bitter (which I put down to that particular batch/season of Motueka - a character I also noted in similar vintages of other NZ beers like Emersons Pilsener and Mac's SR), and not quite dark/red enough. It smoothed out with age, and grew on me once I noticed the similarities with commercial examples, but was definately not how I wanted it. I didn't really like the S04 either.
And after all that I have a mild fermenting now on 1028 and plan to brew something much closer to my original recipe when the mild's done, as it was a ripper of a beer, regardless of it's mongrel-like nature!
Oh and thanks Brad for taking the initiative of actually asking the brewery.