Melbourne Brewers Beerfest, 2013

[Andyd]

If I'm still getting feedback in 2104 than I'll be excited regardless of its content.

Hoping to make a decent beer by then at least .

Thanks for the explanation Andy, makes sense to me now.

No sweat JC - brew long and prosper....

Andy

 

[brettprevans]

Its bloody hard work finding judges not andys fault nor melb brewers. As it was they didnt have enough judges. So I completely sympathise.

 

[jc64]

Its bloody hard work finding judges not andys fault nor melb brewers. As it was they didnt have enough judges. So I completely sympathise.

Maybe my comments have been misconstrued. I admire the time the judges have put in so the competition can be held.

I only wanted to see how the three judges come to make there decisions, being that there was such a big difference in my comments and scores. Andyd answered this perfectly with his explanation.

I certainly don't want to come across as deriding the judges, four of my six scoresheets had really detailed feedback that should really help me make these beers better next time I brew them.

 

[manticle]

I think citymorgue is on the same page as you given his earlier comments.

 

[brettprevans]

Maybe my comments have been misconstrued. I admire the time the judges have put in so the competition can be held.

I only wanted to see how the three judges come to make there decisions, being that there was such a big difference in my comments and scores. Andyd answered this perfectly with his explanation.

I certainly don't want to come across as deriding the judges, four of my six scoresheets had really detailed feedback that should really help me make these beers better next time I brew them.

I think citymorgue is on the same page as you given his earlier comments.

Yup I kinda canned a few judges but im not a tosser as its hard to get judges at vicbrew and I feel obliged to judge despite it not being convenient with family etc. So mants is spot on.

I just wanted to point out the pains of organising a comp as it relies on help and beerfest being the biggest ximp outside vicbrew is a big task.

 

[DUANNE]

does anybody know when prizes will be made availble for pickup?

 

[manticle]

PM me with your entry number and name and I'll sort it out

 

[DUANNE]

thanks manticle.

 

[manticle]

Can any entrants who won trophies or prizes please get in touch with Peter at the Brewer's Den to organise pick up of their material?

9761 1900