I have spent my entire brewing life mainly brewing Lagers. I am sad to say after 100's of brews I am still trying to make the perfect brew. I have come close once with a Bock and again once or twice with festival style German Lagers and got 1st in a local comp with a Schwartzbeir. Anyone can make a Lager but very few can make a great one, worthy of the title.
A few things you should have to make a great Lager are temp controlled fermentation. This is a must. Maybe you could jag some good weather and luck by doing all kinds of crazy things but there is only one way to ferment with accurate temps, and I just duct tape the probe to the outside of the fermenter and tests have shown that the wort is 2 deg warmer so I adjust the controller to suit.
Also a good healthy, active amount of yeast. Remembering that Urquell pitch 15 million cells per ml or wort. (do the math).
But if you keep the recipe simple, i.e. 100% Pils malt, use loads of Saaz plugs preferably, do a two or three step decoction, chill quick after the boil, aeration of the wort should not be a big issue if you pitch enough yeast, Then pitch cold letting it warm up to may 12 deg C, then get it of the yeast cake ASAP, and keg or lager near 0 for as long as possible, and even if you can do all that it isnt worth a pinch of goat **** unless your brewing technique is perfect and you hygiene even better. Even then, if the planets all line up and the beer gods are smiling on you on brew day you have a small chance of making a beer worthy of the name LAGER.
I must admit some of the best ones I have ever made were just luck, I have no idea what made them better than others. I hope now that I am brewing with the Braumeister I can recreate the same beer over and over with more predictability. There were just too many variables using the old 3v system.
Good luck
Steve